EPISODE 45
I know it was unresolved, but did we really need to bring Gunther back? Was anyone clamoring for a resolution to this? We last saw him transformed into stone and beamed into space or something. And here his stone form is just plopped into the middle of battle and he breaks free and...what? It makes no sense. Did anybody even remember him by this point? I think the show hopes you forget how lame he was or that you missed his episodes, because they really want you to believe he's more important than he is.
And, look, I know 20 minutes isn't a lot of time to tell a story, so some shortcuts are taken for the sake of expediency. But the Fiveman look real bad that they're all basically taken down by Shubarie's monster in no time at all. Jetman goes on to rip off this plot for Toranza's last episode -- there he's going around and turning the Jetman into plaques. Here, Shubarie is trapping the Fiveman in stone monuments to present to Meadow. But Jetman spaces apart Toranza's hunting down each Jetman and trapping them; it takes time and there's some plausibility to it. Here, Shubarie challenges the Fiveman to a fight and instantly traps four of them in stone. He takes Gaku back to the Vulgyre where he, too, is soon trapped in stone. OWARI, show. Sorry, chikyuu. Fiveman are losers.
And the day is saved by...Gunther. He's on board the Vulgyre, takes the Gaku-Rock and flees, before being cornered and basically chucking the rock as far as he can with best wishes. This whole scene with Gunther saving the Gaku-Rock is just filmed so unbelievably stupidly, there had to be a better way of depicting all of this. Also? Fuck Gunther! He sucks! Who cares about him? Make this Arthur breaking in to save the day and we'd be talking. We'd actually care about Arthur facing the odds.
The Gaku-Rock ends up in that little area where Garoa's been saving up energy and the day is saved by...the Vulgyre, one of its energy penises pissing on the Gaku-Rock and dissolving the rock, freeing Gaku. Gaku then discovers what none of the Zone have in presumably centuries of their living aboard the Vulgyre -- that the Vulgyre isn't a ship, but a giant beast. I know Soda likes his twists with his head villains, but this is something that he's only started to hint at for the past few episodes and is kind of a big "So what?" A neat idea, in my opinion, but underwhelming as presented by this show.
EPISODE 46
Fiveman's clung to its villains for so long, they have to rush them off. This episode sees the end of Doldora, Zaza and Billion -- Doldora and Billion being the show's two best villains, IMO.
We learn early in the episode that Meadow is just an illusion created by the Vulgyre to manipulate the Zone officers. It's a case of the Zone getting in their own way and ruining their own plans again, because Vulgyre kept the charade for the conquering of 999 planets and couldn't wait for just ONE more before revealing this and possibly alienating his troops?
Doldora has a meltdown that she's been serving a monster all along. Soda's trying to squeeze together Ahames's final moments of desperation and Igam's disgust at working for Lethal Dogler here, but it doesn't work as well as either of those. Nishi's performance is at least good, until Doldora is combined with Zaza and becomes a monster of the week, an unceremonious end for both characters.
The start of the episode is kind of cool, with Gaku stuck aboard the Vulgyre (I keep wanting to type "Fangire") and facing Billion. There's a nice tension to it, like "How the hell's Gaku going to get out of this one?" And the show blows it by having Gunther stumble into the scene and ward off an attack...and they all just kind of fall out of the Vulgyre. Saywhat? Lazy, lazy writing. Heaven forbid the show have a little tension. It might make things too exciting.
Students at the rebuilt school are shown to have grown Shidon flowers to impress Gaku. When the Vulgyre flies over them, Meadow/Vulgyre FLIPS THE FUCK OUT and crashes; it then sends the Doldora monster out to destroy the Shidon flowers, with one student guarding the last one and being pursued. Remember episode 15, when Garoa grew a Shidon flower to coax Gaku out to a fight? In this episode, just flying over a few Shidon flowers causes Meadow/Vulgyre immense pain, but Garoa had one, and Meadow was able to turn it into a monster? Plot hole! I'm sure people pretend like maybe that was a fake flower, but...c'mon, now.
And despite the bad guys being obsessed with the Shidon flower, the Hoshikawas don't realize its importance until their dad gets a message through to them in two episodes. I thought these guys were teachers.
The show, for some reason, overestimates how much we care about Gunther. He takes a fatal hit for Gaku and dies after telling them where their parents are. Gunther...is kind of an asshole. He was saved by the Hoshikawa parents and repaid them by stranding them where they were when he stole the Star Carrier from them, just because he thought the mecha was cool and he has a tiny peepee and needs to overcompensate. He was a pain in the ass in his debut episode when he was challenging everyone to a fight to prove how big his space balls weren't. This character means nothing; it's the show wanting to get in a heroic sacrifice without having to sacrifice anyone who matters -- and it doesn't work. It also makes you realize how this show has a curious lack of meaningful guest or recurring characters that they have to rely on fucking Gunther for the emotional sacrifice. Really, think of it. The show was too afraid to even have romantic interests -- that episode with Yellow Flash barely addressed the idea, but imagine how much more interesting it would have been if she DID have a romantic connection with Gaku and returned for an episode? Oh, well. It's way too late to fix this show.
The action is the best part of this episode, with the Doldora monster attacking four of the Fiveman and having a couple of them strung up on wires, while Five Red has a final sword fight with Billion, which is immortalized in Gaoranger VS Super Sentai. (Sadly, that montage cuts out the coolest part of the fight -- Billion using the underhanded tactic of covering Five Red with his cape and going for the fatal blow, only to discover that Five Red changed into the Five Tector while hidden.)
This is the only one of the final episodes I kind of like.
EPISODE 47
Now it's time for Shubarie and the Gingaman to bite it.
The episode is all about a countdown to the Vulgyre shedding its skin and becoming its true, bestial self. At the exact moment, it needs an enormous energy created by the ultimate death. (It's supposedly the same thing that Vulgyre consumes upon destroying worlds, but...ah, who cares.) Garoa and Shubarie take this to mean the Fiveman's deaths and challenges them to a duel, continuing their little rivalry that nobody cares about.
Shubarie chains himself to Five Red in a final death match. It's a little hard to care, because it's a little too close to the final fight with Billion. Gaku had that rivalry with Garoa that kind of went nowhere, and then he was supposed to have the Classic Niibori Rivalry with Billion because he was a swordsman and then Shubarie comes along and is supposed to be another rival and....ah, who cares. I like how, before fighting Shubarie, Five Red manages to cut off one of Garoa's horns for no good reason. It reminds me of Zack Snyder's Justice League when Superman lasers off on of Steppenwolf's horns. Steppenwolf in that movie is kind of a pathetic loser, but Garoa makes him look like a competent pro.
The big "twist" is that the Vulgyre was hoping for Shubarie's death -- since Shubarie has done so much of the Vulgyre's dirty deeds and murdering, and he has so much blood on his hands, his life is the "ultimate death energy" it wants to use to transform. It would have been nice if any of this was set up, but so much of these final episodes is just rushed and "Oh, shit, we need to start the new show!" And it had to be really motivating for people like Soda to know at this point that Suzuki intended to wipe out the staff in favor for new blood with Jetman.
At least Arthur gets to help pilot the Super Five Robo with the others.
EPISODE 48
Ho-hum. You go from a show that had an outstanding premiere to this really rushed finale. Everyone just couldn't wait to get out of this show, viewers included.
We spend way too much time on a mecha battle with Vulgyre, who ends up really trashing and dismantling the mecha. The Hoshikawas briefly get through to their parents, who tell them of the secret weapon: the Shidon flowers, which they should have already guessed. It's Soda desperately wanting to give the episode some symbolic meaning -- the flowers surviving that attack in the first episode, here bringing about the demise of the attacker -- but that plothole from 15 casts a shadow over it.
The Fiveman raid the Vulgyre with the Shidon flower, encountering the tomb of the real Meadow, who was a regular woman who the Vulgyre loved and she accidentally fell to her death fleeing it in fright. The Vulgyre holds her tomb, her body preserved, using a holographic projection of her image to fool the Zone officers. This has a kind of fairy-tale quality to it and could have made for a better twist if any of it had been hinted at. It just seemed to me like the show was always afraid to have Meadow be the true villain -- they always depicted her so prettily. The Fiveman free Meadow's soul and it assists in destroying Vulgyre -- again, something that would mean more if there had been any hint or build-up to it. I think I would have preferred if Vulgyre had been a creature that loved Meadow and she thought it was ridiculous and wanted to harm it and imprisoned IT by transforming it into a ship and using it.
And, now...Garoa's worst moment, of many worst moments. Things are a-explodin' in the Vulgyre, and he is beating at Meadow's coffin in a panic and then falls into it. We last see him trapped in the coffin, banging at it, trying to get out, as he dies in the explosion once Vulgyre is defeated by eating some Super Five Robo attack. I don't get what the hell they were trying to do with this character. It plays so damn goofily, the circle of making Garoa seem like a buffoon is completed. I don't know if...Garoa is supposed to be so devoted to Meadow, that it's supposed to be kind of touching that he's so shocked that he tries to open her coffin, and it's meant to be some kind of sad twist of fate that he ends up dooming himself with his devotion or...?
I'm thinking of Kiros' end in Maskman. He's already had a mortal wound by being stabbed by a sword. But then he gets REALLY screwed when an icicle stabs him. Kiros was the love-to-hate-him character, a real pain in Red Mask's side since they loved the same woman. His death was meant to make him seem a little pathetic -- not only was the sword that stabbed him a treasure from his collection, but the icicle was a result of Takeru finally breaking Mio free from her ice prison, which had been Kiros' goal in that episode. It was a freak accident and you're kind of like "Damn! Did Kiros deserve that?" I can't tell if it's a similar thing with Garoa, and Ishikawa's performance has just gotten so bad that it plays so stupidly or if they really think that little of the character. "How's our big, bad ass general die?" "He falls into a coffin and gets locked in it and panics!"
I don't even think Garoa cared about Meadow that much, he just cared about being captain. So...whatever, show. I have no fucking idea why this character turned out like this. I can't think of another toku where the serious general villain becomes such a fucking ding-dong. Maybe he's the best representative for this show. Started off strong, but what the fuck happened?
The final scene is the only one that comes close to having some heart and emotion, but Fiveman bungles it. (Of course.) The Sibling Teachers, who don't seem like siblings and haven't done much teaching, bid farewell to a group of their students, so that they can travel to space and find their parents. The nice moment is the students singing a school song for the team, as the team tries to muster up some emotions for these students they barely know, because they're new characters introduced just a couple of episodes ago. The problem is... The school has just been rebuilt...they're free of Zone. And the show STILL doesn't want to make their teacher heroes teachers! The fight's over and they're immediately abandoning their students!
What...was...the point of making them teachers? Takeyuki Suzuki claims he thought the target audience wouldn't care about teacher-student relations. Well, if that was the case, why not shoot that idea down when it was suggested in the boardroom? Why let it make it to production, as a selling point of what makes the show different? At least Tsuburaya admits with Ultraman 80 that they ditched the school setting because it was too expensive. You could have pretended they were teaching off-screen and nobody would notice. As it is, it'd be like Dekaranger being like "Yeah, they're a cop Sentai! But the precinct is destroyed and we follow the characters in their off-hours."
The show also doesn't have the sense to show a scene of the Hoshikawas reuniting. It could have been a quick little thing after the ED credits, Gaku hugging his dad, Fumiya and Remi hugging their mom, everyone joyous, laughing, crying...but, nope. Stay cold and heartless, and barely doing the bare minimum, right through to the end, Fiveman.
Wrap-Up
Fiveman took me the longest to cover of any show I've covered here; I'd watch it on and off and hit patches where I just really didn't want to watch it. A 20-minute show with only 48 episodes should have been a breeze to get through. I don't know if it's because, since Sentai's my favorite of the toku franchises, I hold it to a higher standard than the other franchises (and I hold Hirohisa Soda to a higher standard than most other toku writers) or if it's because Fiveman had such a great premiere and really didn't need to turn out the way it did that it's so maddening to watch. It had the ingredients...
It's clear that, more than running on fumes, they just wanted to coast with this show. It was Suzuki's tenth consecutive show as producer; Soda had been main writer for the past eight but writing for the franchise since its start. Suzuki prided himself on aiming higher with his shows, making them appeal to a general audience and not just kids. When he thought Bioman got too serious, he intended for Changeman to be more lighthearted, but the subject matter of that show again took it to mature places. When he thought Changeman got too heavy, he wanted Flashman to be lighter, but the subject matter again took that show down darker paths. So he stayed on that dramatic path for Maskman, Liveman and Turboranger, wanting to appeal to youths more than just kids. In the late '80s, toku faced some criticisms from parent groups and censors and it effected a lot of the productions. With 1990, you had Winspector, which weren't allowed to have weapons, just rescue tools, and avoided having "scary" monsters. So I think Suzuki went into Fiveman wanting it to be more for the kids than he made his previous shows, and he and the writers fought their natural inclinations to dive deeper into the material. So we end up with a half-hearted production.
Wanting to do a lighter, more kid-friendly show wasn't the problem. The problem was they didn't want to commit to that; it's not the style of Suzuki or Soda or directors like Nagaishi. Their hearts were not into it, and I feel like they mostly used it as an excuse to coast and to shut up censors and parent groups. The proof is in the very concept of them being grade school teachers, only to instantly do away with that. Now add to this that Hirohisa Soda has said he was running on empty by Fiveman and wasn't a fan of the them being teachers. The show is at odds with itself, nobody wanting to commit either way. It doesn't have much life, much heart, much FUN.
I've kept saying the show lacks whimsy, which is what you need if you want something to appeal to youngsters and not have it be totally hollow. Two of my favorite Ultraman shows are Ace and 80. I also like Taro and Cosmos, and all of these shows are accused of being too kid-friendly or having too much goofy filler. But they all have a helluva lot of heart and whimsy. They tap into something that makes you feel nostalgic, makes you think of a timeless folk tale. Some episodes ARE damn goofy, but you can't hate them, because they're filled with so much heart, they're coming from a warm place. Some are just the requisite Lesson-Learnin'™ episodes. There's a difference between going for a timeless fable feel or teaching a lesson and "Eh, the monster this week turns people into dancing marshmallows because this is all stupid and it's for kids and kids don't give a shit." You can picture Fiveman, as a show about grade school teachers, being filled with episodes with plenty of morals and Lesson-Learnin'™, but it doesn't even do that!
I always thought the Dynaman -- scientists who dealt with kids at the Yumeno Invention Center -- often felt like teachers to those kids. Old time Toei producer Shoji Abe worked on Dynaman, and he was always conscious (a little too conscious) of keeping things kid-friendly, so there's a lot of lighthearted episodes in Dynaman. Suzuki and Soda wanting to push things in a different way coupled with things like the reduced run time lent Dynaman a kind of experimental feel after a while; it plays around with its tone, it plays around as it tries to navigate what it is, what it can accomplish in its shorter run time, giving it a sense of fun. The cast all has a great rapport, the action is FAST, FAST, FAST and fiery, it's a bang-for-your-buck thrill ride, where even episodes with a dopey monster or corny lesson will still have something to entertain you with.
There have been shows that have been generic or kid-friendly, and what the writing might lack, the casting will make up for. Ulraman Taro's one of the goofiest shows, but lead Saburo Shinoda is so full of energy and so likable that he holds it all together. Gaoranger's not the strongest show in terms of story, but that cast seems to all like each other and gel. They look like they're having a blast, and they make it enjoyable enough that you want to keep following them...
The Hoshikawa cast isn't up to the job. Not only are they underwritten, seeming like lost guests in their own show, but nobody really seems to enjoy being in the show. Toshiya Fuji isn't a bad actor, and he's likable enough but not exactly super charismatic. Red's the star of the show; a good Red can do a lot of the heavy-lifting if the rest of the cast isn't up to it. A GREAT Red can lift his castmates up and make them all look good. Fuji came from the theater, but he has talked about how it took him a while to get used to what he calls the "exaggerated" acting of toku. So I think he can come across a little awkward, and he doesn't have the strong presence to bolster the side of the heroes. (I also think he was probably disappointed by how the show turned out.) I remember someone who attended a fan event saying that Fuji remarked that he wished he was in a more popular Sentai show -- well, you can put some blame on yourself, Fuji! You could have made more effort!
Kei Shindachiya TRIES as Ken but is never given a lot. I still feel the bigger problem is that Ken and Fumiya are pretty interchangeable; the show doesn't care to differentiate them, so they're just there, and both performers seem lost. Kazumi Miyata is a good actress, a little too good for this show. Keiko Hayase has that Miyauchi Factor, a performer who's just lively and dynamic and talented and made for toku. But we know the heroines aren't going to be the top priority. (The heroes aren't even the top priority in this show, man.) If Fuji had been more invested, been a more charismatic actor, had more enthusiasm, he could have filled some of the emptiness left by the other cast members or whipped everyone into shape. Think of someone who goes above and beyond the requirements, whose dedication unifies the cast, like a Keiichi Wada, Yuuji Kishi or Yasuhisa Furuhara type... You needed that strong center to create a sense of unity and bonding. The Hoshikawas, being the first sibling team, ESPECIALLY needed that. They don't feel like family. AT ALL. (Fuji and Miyata at least look like they could be related.) I tried to think of a Sentai cast that seemed to have less chemistry...Goseiger's the one that jumped out. But even with Goseiger, you had Yasuhiro Takeuchi's performance as Gosei Red influencing Yuudai Chiba to improve and take control of that show; Alata became the strong center the show needed and the series improved for it.
People like to trash Turboranger, but it does so much better than Fiveman. High school heroes were supposed to be a new take, and the show makes more use of that setting, and the younger cast gives the show a different, youthful energy. It pulls off the fairy tale whimsy. It has the strong lead in Kenta Satou, whose enthusiasm bonded most of the cast. The villains were depicted in a dark, horror-like way, and they had a dark fantasy vibe, especially the Nagare Bouma. The show had its own themes and identity.
"Generic as hell" was my response to someone asking me about Fiveman at HJU in '05 when I had first finished the show. But being generic isn't the problem -- being so lifeless and joyless is. It never aims for more than the bare minimum and, even then, frequently falls short of its puny goal. Just such a disappointing "so what" way to end Soda's run, a run that included classic shows and innovations to the franchise, raising the bar for the franchise. It didn't have to turn out this way.
To end this on a brighter note, some of the nice stills from the ED credits, proving that the show's staff WAS capable of emotion, heart and even artistry, the actors capable of joy, but they all chose to abandon that.





























